- February 7, 2019
- Posted by: Thelma Obiakor
- Categories: Africa Development, Opinion
The Lagos State Government has initiated steps towards education sector reforms in the State’s public school system, such as the Lagos Eko Secondary Education Project. These reforms have sought to maximize outcomes by upgrading education infrastructure, strengthening teacher capacity, and adopting information technology for teaching. In some instances, attempts were made to outline teacher competencies, however, there is little evidence of progress made for ensuring that teachers are qualified and have the skills for grades taught, beyond subject expertise. Establishing standards for teacher competence is especially pertinent, as nothing is more fundamental to the success of any educational reform than the quality of teachers who are recruited – and how they are trained, managed and supported.
There is a wealth of both anecdotal and statistical evidence that shows that the quality of an education system cannot surpass the quality of its teaching. In a study conducted by Gbenu JP, where he assessed the state of teacher quality in Lagos State secondary schools, he found that outcomes for quality depend heavily on the quality of the teacher. Though the quality of infrastructure was also an important factor in determining outcomes, he reiterated that it contributed much less than competent teachers. The quality of teaching is, in turn, contingent on the calibre of people recruited, and on the approach to teacher training, preparation, continued professional development, and strategies adopted to ensure retention of skilled individuals.
The demands on education in Nigeria have changed dramatically in the last few decades; there is an increased demand for what students must know and be equipped to do in order to contribute to the nation’s skills needs and to thrive in today’s global world. This demand makes it imperative to invest in education by developing a competency framework for recruiting and selecting competent and effective teachers. A competency framework describes the ideal set of behaviours and traits needed for the teaching profession, and it assures that recruited teachers will perform to the levels and standards required. Competency frameworks have been used successfully in other countries for establishing and improving acceptable standards of teaching. Teacher competencies are a key factor for evaluating the quality of education and have been shown to be the critical most important factor for improving student achievement.
The history of teacher training and certification in Nigeria can be traced back to the introduction of the Teachers Grade III programme, introduced to certify “Pupil Teachers” i.e. elementary school leavers who demonstrated adequate academic ability during their elementary education. Shortly after, the Grade III programme was upgraded to Grade II, with the aim of producing professional elementary school teachers with enhanced academic pedagogical training. However, following a revision of the National Policy on Education (1977), the National Certificate of Education (NCE) became the minimum requirement for elementary school teachers. This resulted in the shortage in availability of qualified elementary school teachers in the State.
As a result, there was a massive drive for teacher recruitment in many parts of Nigeria and existing teacher training colleges were upgraded to NCE-awarding colleges of education. Initially, this program produced new teachers quickly, ensuring that they had the basic requirement for teaching. However, what they produced in quantity, they lacked in quality. With the takeover of mission schools in the ’70s, the introduction of Universal Primary Education, the subsequent overcrowding of classrooms and the opening of new schools by state governments, quality derailed and teacher competence was widely believed to become compromised. However, this poor teacher competence was less a direct function of the policies adopted for increasing access to education than of approaches to teacher recruitment that emphasised paper qualification rather than demonstrable ability. In a bid to fill teacher shortages that became acute during that period, teacher recruitment was indiscriminate, and teaching became one of the least regulated professions in the country, with debilitating effects on the quality of education. This poor quality of education persists today and is indicated by high levels of failure in national examinations, weak educational achievements of students, negative attitudes and the common antisocial behaviour of many school leavers in Nigeria.
Lagos State started to pay some attention to teacher quality in 2005, when – through the policy that created its Education Districts – the State government acknowledged that efficiency and effectiveness of education is a function of teacher quality. The weakness of that and other related policies, however, is two-fold: 1)The failure to properly define teacher quality in relation to desired education outcomes for the State, and to outline a framework for teacher competence that is properly incorporated into recruitment policies; 2)The lack of a Teacher Management Information System (TMIS), fully entrenched within a holistic diagnostic monitoring and evaluation system.
Defining Teacher Quality: Among the school-related factors influencing student achievement, teacher quality is the most important. This is for the simple fact that teachers deliver directly to the students the instructional services that encapsulate learning. While there is no definition of teacher quality that is canonical, broadly speaking, teacher quality delineates on the skills, knowledge, abilities and disposition of teachers. As teaching is substantially a cultural activity, the definition of teacher quality will differ based on a society’s values, concerns, and what the education system is supposed to represent and produce. However defined, the definition must be clear. It must support and benefit continuous teacher development, guide the accreditation of teacher education programs, and must include measurable indicators for assessment purposes. It also needs to be incorporated into a broader framework that articulates the competency standards for teachers working in Lagos State. This competency framework should essentially be a guide that informs decisions on who to hire, retain and promote. It should also represent a continuum of development for teachers; detailing the skills and dispositions entry-level teachers shove have, stipulating the standards of teacher training programs, and finally, pinpointing on the actual results/success they envisage. Successfully implementing such a framework will require data and accurate information that allows decisions makers to make accurate predictions and plans for the training and recruitment of needed teachers. This kind of information ensures that all decisions made about hiring and training are evidence-based.
Teacher Management Information System: A Teacher Management Information System (TMIS) provides the backbone for the collection of the aforementioned data/information. A TMIS is an information system designed to gather teacher information that facilitates decision making about employment and capacity development. It supports the management of teacher recruitment, training, deployment and professional development. A TMIS system is usually composed of information resources (i.e. data and any pertinent documents), the users of the platform (which can include the teachers and decision-makers), and a communication subsystem. These components, where utilized efficiently, contribute to the development of a dynamic ecosystem at the decision making level. This dynamism will be evident in the rate at which information is being uploaded, the relevance of the information being uploaded, and how proactive decision-makers are in using the information to inform decision making. A TMIS can maintain data on a wide range of information, including teacher supply, availability and attrition rates, and it can also be used to sift out unqualified teachers in the system. A TMIS will cover such things as teacher registration, licensing, hiring and performance measures based on the terms and conditions set out in the teacher competency framework. Integrated into the TMIS should be a Teacher Evaluation component that will be used to assess and draw conclusions about teacher performances. On its own, a TMIS system is passive if the information on it is not used to make decisions. An effective TMIS system and its Teaching Evaluation component will incorporate a results-based approach to management, using information and evidence on actual results to inform decision making. It will be utilized beyond its quality control function (for examples, teacher licensing and appraisal) to become a capacity-building tool used to provide support to teachers and to chart the ideal career path for each individual teacher.
Lagos is expected to hire about 130,000 new teachers within the next 10 years to fill vacancies created by the rapid teacher attrition in the state’s public schools. These current attrition rates present the State with an opportunity to examine current and past recruitment efforts, both nationally and worldwide, and to use the findings to inform the development and implementation of a coherent and comprehensive action plan for improving teacher quality. Considerations should be given for identifying individuals with skills appropriate for a range of teaching and related activities in the school, who will be able to provide innovative leadership and drive to ensure the revitalization of schools in the short to medium term. This means that teacher recruitment should not be limited to entry-level and should allow for the adequate complement of skills for individual schools.
In line with attracting the best teachers, this is also an opportunity to position education within the broader vision of development for Lagos State. Governor Ambode has previously expressed his interest in exploring the State’s comparative advantage in order to move the vision of transforming Nigeria’s economic fortunes for the better. A comprehensive framework for recruitment thus presents a corridor to link education to the State’s industrial needs by recruiting teachers who provide education aligned with the State’s needs. Essentially, the right recruitment strategy invites high-quality teachers. High-quality teachers incite quality teaching, and quality teaching breeds required results.
Teachers are the pipeline to the future. The need to recruit highly qualified individuals into the career pipeline and to effectively train them has never been more immediate. A failure to do so will result in negative spillovers, not only for the State but the country at large.